[Verse 1]
I'm reaching out, I said I wouldn’t, but what could I do?
I thought it would be nothing for me, just sewing a wound
And that it would make me stronger just to cut it off forever
And we could both feel light and let it fall
Oh, but baby, this whole time
I've been pretending you're still mine
And the truth is I’m not ready for this at all
Said I needed it, but I'm not ready for this at all

[Chorus]
Don't say you don't care anymore
I don't want to be bitter
I'd rather hurt than nothing
Don't keep your feelings hidden
Just the thought of something new
Makes my whole life shiver
And we're both getting older
Can a first love ever be over?
Don’t you dare give me closure

[Verse 2]
From riding trains to whispering names
Into the moon
But we got perfect, babe
But you know I wouldn’t trade nothing for you
Maybe we'd be stronger if we cut off forever
And we could both feel light and let it fall
Oh, but what’s the point of leaving it
If we can't be forgiving?
I know I shouldn't, but I couldn't help but call
I know I shouldn’t, but I couldn't help but call

[Chorus]
Don't say you don't care anymore
I don't want to be bitter
I'd rather hurt than nothing
Don't keep your feelings hidden
Just the thought of something new
Makes my whole life shiver
We're both getting older
Can a first love ever be over?
Don't you dare give me closure
Don't you dare give me closure

[Bridge]
I've been telling myself I'd be prepared for this
And I thought it would help if I could hear you say it
But, I still want to give you everything
Oh, I still want to give you everything

[Chorus]
Don't say you don't care anymore
I'm sick of being bitter
I'd rather hurt than nothing
Don't keep your feelings hidden
Just thought of the something new
Makes my whole life shiver
And we're both getting older
Can a first love ever be over?

[Outro]
Don't you dare give me closure (Don't you dare)
Don't you dare (Don't you dare)
Don't you dare give me closure
Don't give me closure